Six badges, each earned by a published rule applied to federal data. None of them can be bought, applied for or sponsored. 558 awards went to 420 colleges for 2027, which is 16% of the 2,621 we score.
Because the first version was not, and it failed. Awarding the top 10% nationally on each measure handed a badge to 58% of colleges, and the most decorated were Duke, Penn, Columbia, Rice, Northwestern and Princeton. Nearly every measure of a college correlates with its wealth and its selectivity: well-funded selective colleges retain better, complete better, teach in smaller groups and charge poor families less. So a national top-10% badge mostly restates endowment, and an honor roll that reproduces the existing prestige ranking tells a family nothing it could not already read elsewhere.
Scoping each award to one admissions band within one metro area fixes that. A national reputation buys nothing against the other broad-access colleges in your own city, which is also the comparison most families are actually making. Badges now land on 14% to 17% of colleges in each of the three less selective bands, against 33% of selective ones.
The two rules that are not scoped to a market are scoped to intake instead, comparing a college only with others enrolling a similar share of low-income students. That is the stronger control, and the reason it is used on both completion rules is that completion and return rise together with wealth and selectivity, so a rule requiring both at once is more prestige-correlated than either half, not less.
The rule. The highest total gain after 20 years of any single program, for a family earning $48,000 to $75,000, among colleges in the same admissions band whose nearest major market is this one.
This is the measure the rest of the site is built on: what a graduate is ahead after 20 years, counting four years of net price and the wages given up while studying, weighted by the share who finish.
The rule. Among colleges in the same admissions band that enroll a similar share of Pell Grant recipients, both in the top 15% for the share of students who complete a credential and in the top 15% for what the typical degree returns. At least five measured programs required.
A completion rate on its own does not say whether the credential was worth finishing, and a strong return on its own does not say whether students get to the end of it. This badge replaced a completion-only one for exactly that reason. Return here is the median of the college's measured programs rather than its best, so one strong program cannot carry a college whose others lose money.
The rule. Among colleges in the same admissions band that enroll a similar share of Pell Grant recipients, the top 5% for the share of students who complete a credential.
A raw completion ranking largely reports which students enrolled, so it rewards colleges for their admissions office. Comparing colleges that serve similar student bodies asks a better question: who graduates the students they actually have. No other ranking we know of awards this, and it is the hardest of these to win.
The rule. Every program at the college with published federal earnings returns more than it costs for a family earning $48,000 to $75,000. At least five measured programs required.
Across all colleges 51% of programs do not clear that bar, and 70% of the variation in graduate earnings is between programs at the same college rather than between colleges. A college with no weak program is therefore unusual, and no ranking built on institutional averages can see it.
The rule. The lowest yearly cost after all grant aid for a family earning under $30,000, among colleges in the same admissions band whose nearest major market is this one.
Published price tells a low-income family almost nothing. This is what such families actually paid, as filed with the Department of Education.
The rule. The highest share of first-year students who re-enrolled the following fall, among colleges in the same admissions band whose nearest major market is this one.
Behavior rather than opinion. Continuing costs a student real money, which makes it a far stronger signal than a satisfaction survey.
A badge says where a college stands now, not where it once stood. When the federal data is refreshed the awards are recomputed as a new year rather than rewritten, so nothing that was awarded is ever altered or deleted. But only the current year is shown, and a college that held a badge last year and does not earn it this year no longer displays one. The reason is that the figures underneath move: an award made a year ago rests on a graduating cohort and a retention year that are themselves a year older, and presenting it today would suggest it describes the college as it is now. Where a college is tied for first, every tied college is awarded, which is why a few categories have more winners than markets. The return badge rests on the HEA Group earnings release, a single snapshot with no academic year, so it carries no measurement year where the others do. Full methodology