College Sonar
Compare collegesHow it worksFor colleges

Loading

Explore

Look up a collegeDegrees near youCompare collegesTop degrees by stateWhat colleges are like

Understand

How it worksHow badges are awarded

About

For collegesContact us

College Sonar by Optivara © 2026

Return on a degree

Colleges in this area, compared

5 four-year and 3 open-admission colleges, measured from federal filings. Each list answers one question and the two sectors are ranked separately, because their medians differ too much for a combined list to show anything but which sector a college is in.

Teaching

Students per instructor

four-year colleges · lowest first · 5 measured
  1. Birmingham-Southern College9:1
  2. University of Montevallo13:1
  3. Herzing University-Birmingham14:1
  4. Samford University14:1
  5. University of Alabama at Birmingham18:1

Staying and finishing

Come back after year one

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. Samford University93%
  2. University of Alabama at Birmingham80%
  3. University of Montevallo73%
  4. Herzing University-Birmingham67%
  5. Birmingham-Southern College63%

Finish their credential

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. Samford University71.8%
  2. Birmingham-Southern College55.6%
  3. University of Alabama at Birmingham42.9%
  4. University of Montevallo34.2%
  5. Herzing University-Birmingham12.5%

Cost and aid

Yearly cost, family under $30,000

four-year colleges · lowest first · 5 measured
  1. University of Alabama at Birmingham$13,862
  2. University of Montevallo$13,937
  3. Birmingham-Southern College$17,500
  4. Samford University$22,382
  5. Herzing University-Birmingham$27,308

Get a grant from the college

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. Birmingham-Southern College100%
  2. Samford University100%
  3. University of Montevallo98%
  4. University of Alabama at Birmingham76%
  5. Herzing University-Birmingham74%

Receive a Pell Grant

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. Herzing University-Birmingham95%
  2. University of Alabama at Birmingham42%
  3. University of Montevallo40%
  4. Birmingham-Southern College23%
  5. Samford University11%

The campus

Undergraduates

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 4 measured
  1. University of Alabama at Birmingham10,984
  2. Samford University4,396
  3. University of Montevallo2,112
  4. Herzing University-Birmingham445

Study fully online

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. Herzing University-Birmingham36.8%
  2. University of Alabama at Birmingham18.7%
  3. University of Montevallo18.7%
  4. Samford University0.1%
  5. Birmingham-Southern College0%

Graduate students, share of enrollment

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 4 measured
  1. University of Alabama at Birmingham39.2%
  2. Samford University17.7%
  3. University of Montevallo14%
  4. Herzing University-Birmingham0.9%

Play a varsity sport

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 4 measured
  1. Birmingham-Southern College37.7%
  2. University of Montevallo26.3%
  3. Samford University9.4%
  4. University of Alabama at Birmingham4.4%

Who else is there

Mix of student backgrounds

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. University of Alabama at Birmingham69 of 100
  2. University of Montevallo69 of 100
  3. Birmingham-Southern College47 of 100
  4. Herzing University-Birmingham44 of 100
  5. Samford University28 of 100

Choice of subject

Broad subject areas awarded

four-year colleges · highest first · 4 measured
  1. Samford University24
  2. University of Alabama at Birmingham22
  3. University of Montevallo18
  4. Herzing University-Birmingham5

How to read these. Seven of the thirteen measures have no better end and are ordered as positions only: Pell share, enrollment, graduate share, housing, online study, varsity athletes and background mix. A high Pell share means a college enrolls low-income students, which is a mission rather than a shortcoming, and a commuter campus is often the affordable one. Lists with fewer than 4 colleges reporting are not shown at all, because ordering three colleges is not a ranking. None of these combine into an overall score, since the weights would be our opinion rather than a measurement. The one ranking this product publishes is the return on a degree.

Total gain is what a graduate is ahead after 20 years: what the degree pays above a high-school graduate in the same state, less four years of net price and the wages given up while studying, weighted by the share who finish. Four-year and open-admission colleges, ranked separately and never pooled. At a public college the net price is the in-state one, which is the only version published. Methodology and notes