College Sonar
Compare collegesHow it worksFor colleges

Loading

Explore

Look up a collegeDegrees near youCompare collegesTop degrees by stateWhat colleges are like

Understand

How it worksHow badges are awarded

About

For collegesContact us

College Sonar by Optivara © 2026

Carroll College

Helena, MT

Broad access · 4 of 8 programs pay back

1,065 undergraduates, 12 students for every faculty member · NAIA Division I athletics, and 32% of undergraduates play a varsity sport

What this college is like

Best Financial Gain

Estimated over 20 years

$229k

Registered Nursing Nursing Administration Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing

Worst Financial Gain

Estimated over 20 years

-$270k

Biology General

Customize by family incomeUnder $30k$30k to $48k$48k to $75k$75k to $110kOver $110k
Program20 yr Financial Gain
  1. 1Registered Nursing Nursing Administration Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing$80,878 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 52 graduates$229k
  2. 2Accounting and Related Services$79,048 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 18 graduates$210k
  3. 3Health Services/Allied Health/Health Sciences General$62,284 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 25 graduates$37k
  4. 4Business Administration Management and Operations$60,597 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 20 graduates$20k
  5. 5Teacher Education and Professional Development Specific Levels and Methods$52,448 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 16 graduates-$64k
  6. 6Psychology General$49,321 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 16 graduates-$97k
  7. 7Rehabilitation and Therapeutic Professions$49,309 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 21 graduates-$97k
  8. 8Biology Generalfails federal testIts graduates do not out-earn a typical worker aged 25 to 34 in the same state who has only a high school diploma. That is the U.S. Department of Education's earnings test, and a program that fails it did not beat not going.$32,530 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 17 graduates-$270k
Other colleges to consider

Every college here returns more than this one’s best program, within 250 miles. Only 43% of students here come from MT, so the search is wider than the usual 50 miles: for a college people travel to, the colleges down the road are not the real alternatives.

  1. 1Hyrum Manwaring CenterBrigham Young University-IdahoComputer Science · Rexburg · 193 mi · $117,895 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 44 graduates$499k
  2. 2Washington State University, PullmanWashington State UniversityComputer Science · Pullman · 243 mi · $119,686 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 171 graduates2 campuses$497k
  3. 3Looking NW at Lewis Hall - Montana State University - 2013-07-09Montana State UniversityComputer Science · Bozeman · 80 mi · $111,728 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 90 graduates$465k
  4. 4Montana Technological UniversityPetroleum Engineering · Butte · 48 mi · $106,076 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 64 graduates2 campuses$446k
  5. 5Administrative Building of the University of IdahoUniversity of IdahoComputer Science · Moscow · 236 mi · $103,530 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 33 graduates$378k
  6. 6University Hall - University of MontanaThe University of MontanaComputer and Information Sciences General · Missoula · 94 mi · $91,943 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 20 graduates$231k

Campus photographs: Brigham Young University-Idaho by Ben P L (CC BY-SA 2.0); Washington State University by Jeremy Segrott (CC BY 2.0); Montana State University by Tim Evanson (CC BY-SA 2.0); University of Idaho by Max7 (CC BY-SA 4.0); The University of Montana by Jitze Couperus (CC BY 2.0)

The same programs elsewhere

Holding the subject fixed and changing the college, for this college’s three strongest programs. The list above compares whole colleges at their best; this one answers the narrower question a student who already knows their subject is actually asking.

Registered Nursing Nursing Administration Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing290 colleges pay more
  1. 1Washington State University, PullmanWashington State UniversityPullman · 243 mi · $91,495 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 501 graduates2 campuses$243k
  2. 2Montana Technological UniversityButte · 48 mi · $81,504 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 38 graduates2 campuses$233k

Campus photograph: Washington State University by Jeremy Segrott (CC BY 2.0)

Accounting and Related Services220 colleges pay more
  1. 1Hyrum Manwaring CenterBrigham Young University-IdahoRexburg · 193 mi · $88,548 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 136 graduates$257k

Campus photograph: Brigham Young University-Idaho by Ben P L (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Health Services/Allied Health/Health Sciences General44 colleges pay more, none of them nearby
  1. 1Kips Bay Sep 2026 80Touro UniversityNew York · 1925 mi · $135,742 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 169 graduatesadmits 40-70%$844k
  2. 2Dupont HallUniversity of DelawareNewark · 1873 mi · $107,695 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 35 graduates$641k
  3. 3Valparaiso UniversityValparaiso · 1286 mi · $115,095 annual earnings 4 years after graduation, a median across 18 graduates$596k

Campus photographs: Touro University by Epicgenius (CC BY-SA 4.0); University of Delaware by Mathieu Plourde (CC BY 2.0)

What this college is like

Measured from federal filings, not from a survey. Each figure is compared against four-year colleges, because medians differ too much between sectors for a national comparison to describe anything but the sector.

Teaching
Students per instructor?
12:1
▲fewer students per instructor than 66% of four-year colleges
Staying and finishing
Come back after year one?
82%
▲higher than 70% of four-year colleges
Finish their credential?
54.1%
▲higher than 71% of four-year colleges
Cost and aid
Yearly cost, family under $30,000?
$17,135
▼more expensive than 64% of four-year colleges
Get a grant from the college?
100%
▲a higher share than 100% of four-year colleges
Receive a Pell Grant?
23%
a lower share than 81% of four-year colleges
The campus
Undergraduates?
1,065
smaller than 70% of four-year colleges
Beds per 100 undergraduates?
99
more than 89% of four-year colleges
Study fully online?
0%
fewer than 82% of four-year colleges
Graduate students, share of enrollment?
4.8%
fewer than 86% of four-year colleges
Play a varsity sport?
31.8%
more than 71% of four-year colleges
Who else is there
Mix of student backgrounds?
39 of 100
more concentrated than 84% of four-year colleges
Choice of subject
Broad subject areas awarded?
18
about typical for four-year colleges
Also on record
Women and men
58% / 42%
reported, not ranked
Setting
City
reported, not ranked
On-campus housing
Yes
residential
Athletic division
NAIA Division I
reported, not ranked

More than one undergraduate in five is a varsity athlete. At this level athletics shapes housing, the class schedule and who astudent will meet, whether or not they play.

Compare every college in this metro

Compare Carroll College with another college · up to four side by side, on return and on what each place is like.

26,734Average annual costAfter grants · Family income Over $110k
69%Finish within six years
1,065Undergraduates
71%Applicants admitted

Where students come from

  • Montanain state43%
  • Washington16%
  • Idaho9%
  • Oregon6%

Share of the 284 students who entered as first-year undergraduates in 2024. The states shown are the three largest outside Montana, so these do not add to 100%.

At a glance
SettingCity
Undergraduates?1,065
Graduate students54
Accepts71%
Admitted students who enroll?22%
WebsiteVisit carroll.edu
AdmissionsAY2024
Applicants1,854
Admitted1,315
Enrolled284
SAT middle 50%?1050-1300
ACT middle 50%21-27
Test scores?considered but not required
CostAY2022
Published price?$40,352
Room and board$11,624
Full year’s cost after grants, by income
Under $30k$17,135
$30k-$48k$16,991
$48k-$75k$20,334
$75k-$110k$23,627
Over $110k$26,734
Aid · AY2023
Average grant?$28,737 to 100%
Pell students?23%
Federal loan debt · October 2026
Students who borrow?38%
Owed at graduation?$21,500
Monthly, over 10 years?$244/mo
Owed if they leave early?$5,500
Outcomes2018 cohort
Graduate in 4 years54%
Graduate in 6 years69%
Return after year 1?82%
Students per faculty12:1
Most-awarded programs, bachelor'sAY2025
Registered Nursing Nursing Administration Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing45 degrees
Business Administration Management and Operations23 degrees
Health Services/Allied Health/Health Sciences General22 degrees
Biology General21 degrees
Psychology General14 degrees
AthleticsAY2024
DivisionNAIA Division I
Athletes342
Share of undergraduates?32%
Athletic aid$3,047,421

More than one undergraduate in five is a varsity athlete. At this level athletics shapes housing, the class schedule and who a student will meet, whether or not they play.

StudentsAY2024
Women / men58% / 42%
White78%
Hispanic7%
Two or more5%
Black1%
Asian1%

Notes and sources

Total gain after 20 years is what a graduate is ahead at that point: what the degree pays above a high-school graduate in the same state, less four years of net price and the wages given up while studying, weighted by the share of students who finish. At this college that share is 69%, and it is the same for every program on this page because the federal data reports completion for the institution rather than for individual programs. Four-year and open-admission colleges are ranked separately and never pooled.

Annual earnings 4 years after graduation is the median earnings of that program’s graduates at that point, for students who received federal aid, and is published by program. There is no program-level cost anywhere in the federal data, so net price is the college’s figure applied to each program alike. That is sound for ordering programs against one another and should not be read as a precise figure for any one of them.

Cost on this page is always net price, never the published sticker price. Net price is the college’s full cost of attendance for a year, meaning tuition, required fees, books and supplies, and housing and food, with grant and scholarship aid from federal, state and institutional sources subtracted. Loans are not subtracted, because a loan is not a discount. It is an average for first-time full-time undergraduates receiving federal aid, reported by the college in the income bands shown, so it describes a typical family in that band rather than any particular one. A student living at home, paying out-of-state rates or holding an outside scholarship will not see this figure.

Federal loan debt comes from the College Scorecard and is a median among students who borrowed, not an average across everyone. A college where few students take loans can show a high figure and a small bill for most families, so the share who borrow is printed above it and neither should be read without the other. It counts federal student loans only: private loans and Parent PLUS borrowing are not in it and are not published anywhere comparable, which makes this a floor on what a family owes rather than a total. The figure for students who leave without finishing is the same loans without the degree they were taken for. Default rates are deliberately absent: federal repayment was suspended, so the published three-year rate is zero at almost every college in the country and says nothing about any of them.

Most-awarded programs are degrees conferred in AY2025, first majors only, so a double major counts once. Where two programs are within a few degrees of each other the order between them is not meaningful.

What this college is like compares each measure against four-year colleges, because medians differ too much between sectors for a national comparison to describe anything but the sector. A position of “higher than 90%” means the college matches or beats nine in ten of them on that measure, which is why the measured figure is printed beside it. Six of those measures have a better end and carry a mark; the rest are positions with no better end and carry none. There is no overall score, because combining them would need weights and the weights would be our opinion rather than a measurement.

Sources. IPEDS, the Department of Education’s annual survey, except where stated. Each block in the column beside shows its own year, because the underlying files are released on different schedules and a single date across all of them would be false. Published tuition is a sticker price and is never used as a cost; net price is. Test scores are the middle 50% of enrolled students who submitted a score, not of admitted applicants, which is why they differ from the figures other guides print. Where a US News rank is shown it is the current edition, published as a fact about the college rather than an endorsement of the ranking.

Full methodology