College Sonar
Compare collegesHow it worksFor colleges

Loading

Explore

Look up a collegeDegrees near youCompare collegesTop degrees by stateWhat colleges are like

Understand

How it worksHow badges are awarded

About

For collegesContact us

College Sonar by Optivara © 2026

Return on a degree

Colleges in Amherst, MA, compared

5 four-year and 0 open-admission colleges, measured from federal filings. Each list answers one question and the two sectors are ranked separately, because their medians differ too much for a combined list to show anything but which sector a college is in.

Teaching

Students per instructor

four-year colleges · lowest first · 5 measured
  1. Amherst College6:1
  2. Smith College8:1
  3. Mount Holyoke College9:1
  4. Hampshire College13:1
  5. University of Massachusetts-Amherst17:1

Staying and finishing

Come back after year one

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. Amherst College97%
  2. Smith College94%
  3. University of Massachusetts-Amherst92%
  4. Mount Holyoke College89%
  5. Hampshire College78%

Finish their credential

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. University of Massachusetts-Amherst75.6%
  2. Smith College75.2%
  3. Mount Holyoke College74.2%
  4. Amherst College72.6%
  5. Hampshire College51.1%

Cost and aid

Yearly cost, family under $30,000

four-year colleges · lowest first · 5 measured
  1. Amherst College$4,625
  2. University of Massachusetts-Amherst$6,061
  3. Mount Holyoke College$7,687
  4. Smith College$11,678
  5. Hampshire College$19,536

Get a grant from the college

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. Hampshire College100%
  2. University of Massachusetts-Amherst80%
  3. Mount Holyoke College77%
  4. Smith College67%
  5. Amherst College59%

Receive a Pell Grant

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. Hampshire College39%
  2. Mount Holyoke College19%
  3. Amherst College18%
  4. University of Massachusetts-Amherst18%
  5. Smith College16%

The campus

Undergraduates

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. University of Massachusetts-Amherst25,290
  2. Smith College2,786
  3. Mount Holyoke College2,330
  4. Amherst College2,094
  5. Hampshire College808

Beds per 100 undergraduates

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. Hampshire College146
  2. Amherst College93
  3. Mount Holyoke College92
  4. Smith College89
  5. University of Massachusetts-Amherst57

Study fully online

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. University of Massachusetts-Amherst3.9%
  2. Amherst College0%
  3. Hampshire College0%
  4. Mount Holyoke College0%
  5. Smith College0%

Who else is there

Mix of student backgrounds

four-year colleges · highest first, no better end · 5 measured
  1. Amherst College79 of 100
  2. Smith College70 of 100
  3. Mount Holyoke College67 of 100
  4. University of Massachusetts-Amherst64 of 100
  5. Hampshire College59 of 100

Choice of subject

Broad subject areas awarded

four-year colleges · highest first · 5 measured
  1. University of Massachusetts-Amherst28
  2. Smith College19
  3. Hampshire College18
  4. Amherst College17
  5. Mount Holyoke College16

How to read these. Seven of the thirteen measures have no better end and are ordered as positions only: Pell share, enrollment, graduate share, housing, online study, varsity athletes and background mix. A high Pell share means a college enrolls low-income students, which is a mission rather than a shortcoming, and a commuter campus is often the affordable one. Lists with fewer than 4 colleges reporting are not shown at all, because ordering three colleges is not a ranking. None of these combine into an overall score, since the weights would be our opinion rather than a measurement. The one ranking this product publishes is the return on a degree.

Total gain is what a graduate is ahead after 20 years: what the degree pays above a high-school graduate in the same state, less four years of net price and the wages given up while studying, weighted by the share who finish. Four-year and open-admission colleges, ranked separately and never pooled. At a public college the net price is the in-state one, which is the only version published. Methodology and notes